How to pass a prop firm challenge: size your risk to the rules.

A prop firm challenge is passed or failed mostly by your risk per trade, measured against the firm’s daily and max loss limits. In 10,000 simulated attempts at a 10% target with a 5% daily and 10% max loss, a trader with a 45% win rate and 1.5R reward passed 84.8% of the time risking 1% a trade, but only 44.6% risking 2%, and most of those failures hit the daily limit.

The rules you are playing against

Every challenge has a profit target and at least two loss limits. FTMO’s 2-Step Challenge is a common reference point:

  • Profit target: 10% in the Challenge, then 5% in the Verification.
  • Maximum daily loss: 5% of the initial capital, counted from each day’s starting balance and including open trades.
  • Maximum loss: 10% of the initial capital, static: on a $100,000 account your equity must stay above $90,000.
  • Minimum trading days: 4.

FTMO’s 1-Step Challenge is stricter on losses: a 3% daily limit, a 10% max loss that trails your highest end-of-day balance, and a consistency rule on your best day. Other firms use other numbers, so start from your own firm’s rule page.

What 10,000 simulated attempts show

We ran the Challenge phase above (10% target, 5% daily, 10% static max, 4 minimum days, no time limit) for a trader who wins 45% of trades, wins 1.5R and loses 1R. That is a real edge of +0.125R per trade. Only the risk per trade changes from row to row.

45% win rate, 1.5R reward, 3 trades a day. 10,000 simulated attempts per row.
Risk per tradePassedHit the daily limitHit the max lossMedian trading days to pass
0.25%99.5%0%0.1%94
0.5%96.1%0%3.9%42
1%84.8%0%15.2%15
2%44.6%54.5%0.9%4
3%40.5%58.6%0.9%4

Two things stand out. Below 1% risk, the pass rate is very high but slow: at 0.5% the typical pass took 42 trading days. Above 1%, the pass rate drops fast, and the daily limit does most of the damage. At 2% risk, three losses in one day is −6%, past the 5% limit; at 3%, two losses are enough.

Simulated with Journaly’s free challenge simulator: 10,000 attempts per row with a fixed seed, 3 trades a day, every trade risks the same % of the starting balance and either loses 1R or wins the full reward, wins and losses are independent, and the max loss is static. Costs and slippage are left out.

Your edge decides whether lower risk helps

Smaller risk only helps if the strategy makes money on average. Edge per trade is win rate × reward − loss rate (see trading expectancy). Here is the same challenge for four traders:

Pass rate by edge and risk per trade. Same rules as above.
Win rate and rewardEdge per trade0.5% risk1% risk2% risk3% risk
50%, 2R+0.5R100%99.1%69.9%58.9%
45%, 1.5R+0.125R96.1%84.8%44.6%40.5%
40%, 1.5R+0R49.1%49.9%30.8%30.5%
40%, 1.2R−0.12R1.8%11.3%16.8%20.1%

With a positive edge, lower risk gives the edge time to work, so the pass rate climbs. With no edge (40% at 1.5R), the result is close to a coin flip at any sensible size. With a negative edge (40% at 1.2R), smaller risk makes things worse, because the losses have more time to add up; the best row still fails about 4 attempts in 5. No position size turns a losing strategy into a passing one.

A plan that follows from the numbers

  1. Measure your edge first. Take win rate, average win and average loss from your own logged trades, after costs. If expectancy is not above zero, fix the strategy before you buy a challenge.
  2. Make a full losing day survivable. Keep trades per day × risk per trade below the daily limit. At 1% risk and 3 trades a day, the worst day is −3%, inside a 5% limit; in the simulation, no 1% attempt ended on the daily limit.
  3. Check the time. Lower risk takes longer. If your firm has a time limit, put it into the simulator and see how many attempts run out of days.
  4. Count the cost per pass. A fee divided by the pass rate is what one pass really costs. Track fees and payouts together in the challenge calculator.

Sources

Checked on 16 Nov 2026. Firms change their rules, so check your own firm’s current rule page before you trade.

Journaly is a trading journal. This article is general education, not financial advice.

Questions.

Journaly

What risk per trade should I use for a prop firm challenge?

There is no single right number; it depends on your edge and the firm’s limits. In 10,000 simulated attempts at a 10% target with 5% daily and 10% max loss, a 45% win rate at 1.5R passed 96.1% at 0.5% risk, 84.8% at 1% and 44.6% at 2%. Run your own numbers in the free simulator.

Why does risking more make a challenge harder to pass?

Because the daily loss limit is small next to the target. At 2% risk and three trades a day, three losses in one day is −6%, past a 5% daily limit. In the simulation, 54.5% of 2%-risk attempts ended on the daily limit.

Can a higher win rate alone get me through?

Only together with reward-to-risk. A 40% win rate at 1.5R has zero edge, and passed close to half the attempts at any risk size. Edge per trade is win rate × reward − loss rate.

Read next.

Try Journaly on Android today.

The beta is free on Google Play. Three taps, with the Google account you use on your phone:

  1. Join the Journaly testers group (tap “Join group”)
  2. Become a tester (tap “Become a tester”)
  3. Install Journaly from Google Play

Something wrong or missing? Post it on the Feedback board in Profile. Beta testers shape what ships at launch.

On iPhone? Be first in line.

Journaly is on Android now and the App Store is next. Leave your email for the iPhone beta and launch day.

Only launch news. Unsubscribe any time.