Trading expectancy: the number that says whether your edge is real.

Expectancy is what you make or lose on an average trade: win rate × average win − loss rate × average loss. A trader who wins 45% of trades, makes 1.5R on a win and loses 1R on a loss has 0.45 × 1.5 − 0.55 × 1 = +0.125R per trade. Above zero, the strategy makes money over many trades; at or below zero, no position size fixes it.

The formula

Expectancy = (win rate × average win) − (loss rate × average loss)

Use net figures, after commission, swap and fees. In money, it is the average profit per trade. In R (multiples of what you risk), it lets you compare strategies with different sizes.

Worked example

Made-up numbers: 40 trades, 18 wins averaging $300 and 22 losses averaging $200.

  • Win rate 45%, loss rate 55%.
  • Expectancy = 0.45 × $300 − 0.55 × $200 = $135 − $110 = $25 per trade.
  • Check: total profit $5,400 − total loss $4,400 = $1,000, and $1,000 ÷ 40 trades = $25.
  • Profit factor = $5,400 ÷ $4,400 = 1.23. Expectancy is above zero exactly when profit factor is above 1.

Breakeven win rate

Set expectancy to zero and you get the win rate you need for a given reward-to-risk: breakeven = 1 ÷ (1 + R).

Win rate needed to break even, before costs.
Reward-to-riskBreakeven win rate
0.5R66.7%
1R50.0%
1.5R40.0%
2R33.3%
3R25.0%

Costs move every row up a little, because they make each win smaller and each loss larger.

What edge does to a prop firm challenge

In 10,000 simulated attempts at a 10% target with a 5% daily and 10% max loss, risking 1% a trade and taking 3 trades a day:

Pass rate at 1% risk by edge per trade.
Win rate and rewardEdge per tradePassed
50%, 2R+0.5R99.1%
45%, 1.5R+0.125R84.8%
40%, 1.5R+0R49.9%
40%, 1.2R−0.12R11.3%

A zero edge gives about even odds of hitting the target before the max loss, because both are 10% away. A negative edge loses most attempts. The full table with other risk sizes is in how to pass a prop firm challenge.

Simulated with Journaly’s free challenge simulator: 10,000 attempts per row with a fixed seed, 3 trades a day, every trade risks the same % of the starting balance and either loses 1R or wins the full reward, wins and losses are independent, and the max loss is static. Costs and slippage are left out.

Measure it from your own trades

Expectancy is only as good as the trades behind it. Log every trade with its net P&L, including the ones you would rather forget, and recompute it as the count grows: a short run of trades can make a weak strategy look good. MetaTrader 5 reports show it as “expected payoff” (see exporting MT5 history).

Sources

Checked on 16 Nov 2026. Firms change their rules, so check your own firm’s current rule page before you trade.

Journaly is a trading journal. This article is general education, not financial advice.

Questions.

Journaly

What is a good trading expectancy?

Any expectancy above zero after costs means the strategy made money per trade over the sample. In R it is easier to compare: +0.1R means you made a tenth of your risk per trade on average.

Is expectancy the same as profit factor?

No, but they agree on the sign. Profit factor is total profit ÷ total loss; expectancy is the average result per trade. Expectancy is above zero exactly when profit factor is above 1.

What win rate do I need with a 1:2 risk-to-reward?

Before costs, 33.3%: breakeven win rate = 1 ÷ (1 + 2). Costs push it a little higher.

Read next.

Try Journaly on Android today.

The beta is free on Google Play. Three taps, with the Google account you use on your phone:

  1. Join the Journaly testers group (tap “Join group”)
  2. Become a tester (tap “Become a tester”)
  3. Install Journaly from Google Play

Something wrong or missing? Post it on the Feedback board in Profile. Beta testers shape what ships at launch.

On iPhone? Be first in line.

Journaly is on Android now and the App Store is next. Leave your email for the iPhone beta and launch day.

Only launch news. Unsubscribe any time.